Group projects in the classroom can either be a rewarding experience — or a chaotic mess. The way you choose groups for class projects plays a crucial role in setting the tone for collaboration, productivity, and student satisfaction. But let’s be real: there’s no single “best way” to assign groups. How you assign student groups for class projects depends heavily on the profile of your class and the social dynamics at play.
In this post, I’ll walk you through the best strategies for assigning groups to match your class dynamics, drawing on real-world classroom experience and insights into group psychology (see my deep dive on leveraging group psychology). Whether you assign groups randomly, let students pick their partners, or hand-pick groups strategically, the key is knowing which approach fits your class — and when to use it. Let’s dive in.
Subscriber-Only Resource Below 👇
1. Random Assignment: A Fair Way to Choose Student Groups for Class Projects
Using a random method to assign groups — like drawing names from a hat or using an online tool (more ways here) — is often the fairest way to handle group work in class projects. This strategy ensures every student gets a chance to work with different peers, breaking up cliques and avoiding accusations of favouritism.
When to Use This Strategy:
- Socially balanced classes with students who generally get along.
- Projects that don’t require highly specific roles or skill sets.
Teacher Insight:
Randomly assigned groups can disrupt strong social dynamics, forcing students to collaborate with new classmates. If you sense potential awkwardness, start with a quick icebreaker to get things going.
2. Letting Students Choose Their Own Groups: Freedom with Boundaries
Allowing students to pick their own groups can be empowering, but it’s not without risks. Students tend to gravitate toward their closest friends, which can boost creativity but may also leave some classmates feeling excluded. Balancing freedom with structure is key here, especially for class projects that require teamwork.
When to Use This Strategy:
- Creative class projects or tasks that benefit from strong pre-existing relationships.
- When your students are mature and socially responsible enough to make good choices.
Teacher Insight:
If you decide to let students pick, set boundaries:
- Allow students to pick one partner they want to work with, and then assign the rest of the group yourself.
- Pre-approve choices to ensure no one is left out.
This way, you’ll harness the benefits of student choice while keeping things fair.
3. Teacher-Assigned Groups: The Best Strategy for Managing Group Dynamics in Class Projects
Sometimes, strategically assigning groups is the best way to ensure balanced collaboration. This strategy lets you manage group dynamics by pairing strong personalities with quieter ones or mixing students based on ability and leadership traits. If your class has complex social dynamics, this method ensures that every student has a fair shot at contributing.
When to Use This Strategy:
- Projects that require specific roles or responsibilities (e.g., researcher, presenter, organiser).
- When social dynamics need careful management to avoid disruptions.
Teacher Insight:
This strategy works best when you have a good sense of who influences the class and how students interact. Pairing classroom leaders with quieter students can help everyone grow, but make sure no one feels overshadowed.
4. Mixed-Ability Groups: Balance Skills for Class Projects That Require Peer Learning
Creating mixed-ability groups ensures that students with different strengths work together. This method promotes peer learning, as students with stronger skills help others catch up, while everyone plays an important role.
When to Use This Strategy:
- Academic tasks that require a range of skills (e.g., problem-solving, research, and presentation).
- Projects that aim to promote peer learning and equal contribution.
Teacher Insight:
Assign specific roles within the group to prevent stronger students from taking over. For example:
- One student acts as the organiser, keeping the group on track.
- Another focuses on research and fact-finding.
- A third student presents the final product.
By dividing responsibilities, everyone in the group contributes meaningfully, and the work is shared more evenly.
5. Interest-Based Groups: Use Shared Passions to Boost Engagement in Class Projects
One way to choose groups for class projects is to organise students based on shared interests. This works especially well for long-term projects or tasks where intrinsic motivation plays a big role. When students care about the topic, they’re more likely to stay engaged and put in extra effort.
When to Use This Strategy:
- For creative projects or tasks that require open-ended exploration.
- When you want to tap into student passions to boost motivation.
Teacher Insight:
Survey your students ahead of time to find out what they’re interested in, then group them accordingly. You can either group students with similar interests or mix them intentionally to spark new ideas. Just be mindful — interest-based groups can lead to off-task chatter, so set clear expectations from the start.
6. Rotating Groups: Build Adaptability and Social Skills Through Class Projects
Rotating groups throughout the term ensures that students work with a wide variety of classmates, building social skills and adaptability. This strategy helps prevent cliques and gives everyone the chance to experience different roles within a team.
When to Use This Strategy:
- Long-term projects where students can switch roles over time.
- When your goal is to develop social skills and encourage teamwork across the class.
Teacher Insight:
When rotating groups, introduce new phases or tasks with each change to keep things fresh. This way, students stay engaged, even as they adapt to new group dynamics.
Grade the Process, Not Just the Product: Add Group Work Skills to the Rubric
No matter how you choose groups for class projects, make sure students know that their ability to work well with others is part of their assessment. Add collaboration and teamwork to your rubric to show that the process matters just as much as the product.
This approach also ties back to the strategies mentioned:
- Random groups: Students learn to adapt to new partners.
- Student choice: They’re responsible for their decisions.
- Teacher-assigned groups: Everyone must fulfil their role effectively.
- Mixed-ability groups: Students are expected to contribute equally.
- Interest-based groups: Passion shouldn’t overshadow teamwork.
- Rotating groups: Success means adapting to new dynamics.
🎁 Exclusive Resource: Want to make teamwork count in your class projects? Subscribe below to unlock my ready-to-use Teamwork Rubric Add-On. 👇
Final Thoughts
Knowing how to choose groups for class projects is as much about understanding your students as it is about assigning roles. The right strategy depends on the nature of the task and the social dynamics of your class. Some days, random groups keep things fair, while other days, teacher-assigned groups help balance personalities and abilities.
Experiment with these strategies, and over time, you’ll find the approach that works best for your class. Remember, the goal isn’t just to complete the project — it’s to help your students collaborate, adapt, and grow. And by including group skills in your rubric, you set clear expectations from the start and show students that how they work together is just as important as what they produce.
Do you have a favourite strategy for forming groups? Drop your tips in the comments—I’d love to hear what works for you!
Free Resource
Really appreciate you being part of this growing community. Follow this link to the ready-to-use Teamwork Rubric Add-On.
